These are not variations on one problem. Tower isolation is about keeping dirty water away from clean equipment; free cooling is about how many hours a year the chillers can stop; oil cooling is a viscosity problem; product chilling is a quality problem. What they share is that the dirtier side, not the calculation, sets the design.
The coolant available and its supply temperature, which on tower water varies seasonally. Fouling on both sides based on real water quality rather than a table. Allowable pressure drop. And whether the process stream carries anything a narrow channel would block.
A plate pack opens completely, so the fouling side can be reached and cleaned rather than only flushed. Where the stream is solids-bearing, the Free-Flow plate or a Temp-Plate bank handles what a conventional pack will not. Where near-freezing water is needed, a falling film chiller makes it directly.
Open cooling tower water is dirty, biologically active and full of dissolved solids. Isolating it from a...
+ Learn More
When the outside air is cold enough, the cooling tower alone can meet the load and the chillers can stop. A...
+ Learn More
Oil is viscous, which makes it a poor heat transfer fluid, and hot oil is a maintenance problem waiting to...
+ Learn MoreAs much as your own water quality and cleaning history support, and no more. Excessive allowance produces an oversized unit running at low velocity when clean, which encourages the deposition it was meant to cover.
Cooling tower supply temperature follows wet bulb, so the hot humid day is the worst case. If the exchanger was sized on an optimistic supply assumption, summer is when that shows up.
On a plate exchanger both sides open, so it matters far less than on a design that cannot be opened. What matters more is choosing a plate pattern and velocity that discourage deposition in the first place.
When you need water near freezing. A plate exchanger transfers heat between two streams; it cannot make one colder than the coolant available. A falling film chiller is a refrigeration evaporator and makes cold water directly.